Honest Little Apps

The Misfiled Museum Photo

Investigate a fictional museum photograph by comparing signs in the image, dated notices and a later caption.

Start the activity

A printed caption says “Pier opening, 1931.” A clear banner in the photo says “Repairs complete, October 1934.”

Which clue should you investigate first?

Use this activity

Separate what the evidence proves from what it only suggests. The case uses fictional sources.

Review the cases

Case 1 · Which clue should you investigate first?

A printed caption says “Pier opening, 1931.” A clear banner in the photo says “Repairs complete, October 1934.”

The banner visible in the photo The words visible in the scene challenge the caption directly.

Case 2 · What can the notice establish?

A newspaper notice dated 8 October 1934 announces a reopening for 13 October. It does not describe the photograph.

The reopening was planned for 13 October A notice confirms what was announced. The photo date still needs another link.

Case 3 · What should the new catalog note say?

A dated contact sheet contains the same image and names the 1934 reopening.

Use “1934 reopening,” citing the contact sheet The dated contact sheet connects the specific image to the event, making the more precise caption defensible.

Related browser activities