Honest Little AppsBrowse free tools

Learning & puzzles

What can one photograph prove?

Use a Library of Congress photograph to separate observation, catalogue evidence and inference in a three-question history lesson.

Inspect the photograph

A woman sits with her hand against her face. Two children turn inward beside her and a smaller child lies in her lap.
Dorothea Lange, Nipomo, California, March 1936. Farm Security Administration collection, Library of Congress.
Compare the unretouched printThe unretouched print includes a thumb at the lower right edge

Look near the lower right edge. The Library of Congress identifies the thumb in this print and its removal in the other version.

Unretouched print, Library of Congress

Teacher notes and source record

Ask for one sentence beginning “I see…” and one beginning “The catalogue says…”. The image alone can show a gesture. A date or location calls for a source beyond what is visible.

The catalogue credits Dorothea Lange and identifies Nipomo, California, March 1936. The Library of Congress guide also identifies a version printed before a foreground thumb was retouched. Compare the versions before interpreting the edit.

Library of Congress photograph and catalogue record

Library of Congress guide to the different frames and prints

QR code for PastRush: History Detective on the App Store
PastRush: History Detective
Investigate more source-based cases in PastRush.
Scan for the App Store listing. Worksheet by Honest Little Apps.